This oil spill? Not BP’s fault. Not really.

by Miss Britt on June 1, 2010

Like many people, I can’t bring myself to look away from the constant updates about the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico.

There’s something about this spill that seems more personal than previous ones.  Bigger.  More prophetic, or something. Maybe it’s because I live in Florida now, or maybe it’s because it’s still spilling, after all this time.  Or maybe it’s because, the today’s climate of environmental responsibility, it’s too hard to ignore my part in it.

I keep reading amazing stories and tributes to the Gulf.  People want to do something, anything to help.  We’re angry and scared and overwhelmed and, I think, all feeling a little helpless.

And I think we can all agree that we’re pretty pissed off at BP, the company that owns the oil that’s currently flowing into the Gulf unchecked.

But maybe we need to be a little angry at ourselves, too.

I’ve heard people say, “all BP cares about is money,” and my first though is – of course that’s what they care about. They are a company with shareholders and employees and executives to answer to.  The only reason BP exists is to generate income.  Their job, as a profit-generating entity, is to figure out how to meet consumer need in a way that makes as much money as possible.  Their entire purpose, ironically, is to plug a hole that the markets create.

Our job, as consumers, is to decide what that need is.

We make the hole.

But we already know this, don’t we?  On some level, as we watch the shoreline for signs of destruction and wonder how bad it is in places where we can’t watch, we have a nagging in the back of our minds that says, we did this.

We did this with our SUVs and V-8 engines.  We did this with our sprawling suburbs and commuter lifestyles.  We did this by failing to encourage the spending tax dollars for public transit systems, refusing to use public transit systems that exist, purchasing goods that need to be transported from miles away when local alternatives exist, valuing comfort and luxury over efficient use of our resources, and generally just neglecting to ask if we should have it just because we can.

As one writer put it:

“the fact that the US is drilling over a mile below the surface in one of its most important marine ecosystems is directly related to US consumption of oil: the highest in the world.”

It is embarassing how much more petroleum we consume than other countries.  According to the US Department of Energy, the United States used more than 19 million barrels per day in 2008, compared to only 7.9 million barrels per day used by China, the second largest consumer of oil.

So we can yell and protest and rage against BP all we want.  We can even be pissed off at our government for failing to do more to ensure “safer” drilling or continuing to divert our tax dollars to keeping oil companies strong.  But in the end, we did this.

Now the question is – what are we going to do about it?

Will we bemoan this tragedy and use it as the latest reason for us to play human, before moving on to the next cause?  Because there will inevitably be a next cause.  The world is constantly supplying us with reasons to cry and help and love harder and rethink.  But unlike earthquakes or hurricanes or other causes that we can only hope to survive and clean up – this tragedy was made by our own hands.  This tragedy could have been prevented, and we can prevent it from happening again.

But how?

I don’t know.  I’ve been turning this over and over in my head, and it’s overwhelming.  It’s hard not to feel like nothing I do could matter, really.  We may be able to get rid of the SUV we have now, or use it much less frequently.  Maybe we can find a more efficient way to do our shopping locally and look for products that aren’t grown or made closer to home.  Long term, I’d like to live in a place where I can walk or use public transit for most of my daily transportation needs.

I’m not sure what the answer is, but I know my family needs to go on a petroleum diet.

Maybe it’s because I live in Florida now, but I really do love the Gulf, and I’m so, so sorry for my part in harming it.

ahhhh, the beach

Posted in Serious Discussions - Politics, Religion, Society Tagged: , , , , , ,

34 Comments so far

  1. Mighty Hunter June 1, 2010 7:54 pm

    It’s not to late to help prevent the next one. I’m doing, or at least trying to do, my part. The fact that you are even thinking about this, and understanding that there are no easy answers, means something.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Mighty Hunter, I like to imagine it’s never “too late”, our options just might change.

    I really want to do my part, too. What I think I need to figure out is how to set a measurable goal for my family and what small steps we can consistently take to reach that goal.

  2. MommyTime June 1, 2010 7:58 pm

    Have you seen this post from Queen of Shake Shake? She totally agrees with you. (As so I, by the way) So worth reading: http://tinyurl.com/2cxhz52

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @MommyTime, I hadn’t seen it – thank you so much for sharing it!

  3. Maria June 1, 2010 8:06 pm

    Yep.

  4. Cher June 1, 2010 8:10 pm

    If I can survive the grapefruit and brown rice diets of my youth, I can survive a petroleum diet, as you so aptly put it. Our family has been trimming back over the last year. Every little bit counts. We sold one car, we take the bus, we turn the heat lower, turn off lights, buy local produce…yada, yada. It’s how we lived until about the 1950s. Our gluttony is pretty recent so it seems to me, we can correct it.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Cher, every little bit does count. I live in a suburb/commuter town basically developed with the intention of people living one place and working in another. But I have to figure it out.

  5. A'Dell June 1, 2010 8:12 pm

    This is pretty much what I keep thinking too. I fail to see how this is BP’s *fault* since there was an EXPLOSION and people DIED and it was an ACCIDENT. (Accidents happen!)

    There’s no way BP was purposefully careless with such a huge investment and with employee lives.

    Similarly, if BP could figure out how to stop the flow, they totally would have. I don’t get these people who think they aren’t doing all they can.

    It’s so sad and horrible but you’re spot on – if we didn’t NEED this oil so badly, we wouldn’t be punching holes every where we could think of to get our hands on more of it.

    Sad all the way around.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @A’Dell, I’m sure BP carries a part of the responsibility as well – but I try not to make a habit of worrying about someone else’s responsibilities until I’ve handled my own.

  6. Terri June 1, 2010 8:13 pm

    You just pretty much summarized my recent thoughts on this (and very nicely might I add).

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Terri, it’s encouraging to know that other people are starting to think this way. Maybe we’re more inclined as a society to start implementing some solutions.

  7. Deb Rox June 1, 2010 8:14 pm

    This is the truth. Our complicity is even more reason that we can’t turn away from it, and it’s not as though the oil from Deepwater means that another spill or other disasters can’t also happen.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Deb Rox, I think that’s probably true – it’s hard to ignore that quiet voice of guilt.

  8. Hockeymandad June 1, 2010 8:20 pm

    I know it’s not BP’s fault, but I will still drive past a BP to get gas from another dealer. Heroin is still heroin and we’re all collective junkies, but I cannot give my money to them right now. I don’t feel they’re any greedier than any other major corporation, but I can choose not to support them right now. Plenty of other options to get our fix.

    We do what we can, but I’m afraid its not much. I don’t care how small the drop in the bucket, I am still doing what I can to reduce my footprint on the planet. Sure I could do more, but every little bit helps right? RIGHT?

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Hockeymandad, wait – are you actually DRIVING FURTHER to use another station?

    (Every little bit ALWAYS helps. It’s a belief in that idea that, I think, keeps humanity moving forward.)

    Hockeymandad Reply:

    @Miss Britt, No, I don’t drive further. I just have many options in my 22 mile one way commute. Which I tried to fix as well, but didn’t get the job. Still hurt over that one…

  9. Kathryn June 1, 2010 8:54 pm

    Excellent, honest, and thought-provoking post, Britt.

    I work for one of the other big oil companies. For us (the oil industry, which employs hundreds of thousands directly and probably millions indirectly in this country), this is a tragedy, too. Those were our people that were lost on that rig. Those 11 people who didn’t go home to their families…those were our people. They do a dangerous job so that we can all drive our cars and have all of the other things that our modern society uses. Maybe we don’t need all of those things, we can certainly all probably use less of a lot of them…but millions of American jobs are tied to providing them. We manufacture very little in this country anymore, it’s part of our economic problem. We still manufacture gasoline, and jet fuel, and diesel fuel, and we’re working on making those fuels cleaner and finding alternatives as well. We know that oil is not the energy source of the future, but what I think people fail to realize is how inadequate the alternatives are at this point in time. Oil doesn’t just stop on a dime.

    Anyway…I couldn’t agree more with this post. We are the reason that oil and gas production is needed. Let’s at least be honest with ourselves. I use my canvas grocery bags faithfully. I recycle as much as I can. I see that my company is working on alternative energy and I’m proud to work for them, because the world needs energy. We aren’t going back to the days of candles and horse-and-buggy.

    I, like everyone else, am horrified that seven weeks on, that pipe is still pouring oil into the Gulf. I am sure that BP is, as well. I know that they (with the help of many other experts from other companies, this is an industry problem, not just a BP problem) are doing everything they can to try to figure out how to stop it. Please God let it stop soon.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Kathryn, it’s hard not to think about the jobs associated with oil companies – much like the jobs associated with the space industry here in Florida.

    But at some point, we have to be willing to adjust as a nation, and we haven’t been. As people we abhor change so much that sometimes we actually harm ourselves to avoid it – and I think holding on to old ways of making money instead of embracing new ones is an example of that.

    Kathryn Reply:

    @Miss Britt, Which is why I said that my company is actively engaged in searching out and developing alternative energy sources. This is what people find so hard to grasp, though: our population is what it is. You don’t change from your major source of energy to a new one in a year, or a few years. Joe’s Alternative Energy is a pipe dream, not anything close to realistic for the size of population that we need to supply with energy.

    So while I agree with you that overall we haven’t been willing to adjust, we do see signs of adjustments taking place. We now have 10% renewable fuel blended into our gasoline, that’s a federal mandate. If engines can handle it, that will be upped but it’s questionable right now. We see that we have more fuel-efficient cars and hybrids on the roads. We see people using less plastic, etc.

    But we didn’t get here overnight, and efficient, cost-effective sources of alternative energy won’t be adequate for our energy needs overnight, either. Not to mention that our economy can only take so many hits in the job loss arena. We have seen massive change in the job landscape in the U.S., we are no longer a manufacturing economy but a service economy. It’s eroded our standard of living, job security, worker pay and benefits, etc. It would be so unfortunate to see another segment of employment devastated by hasty action because “all of a sudden”, people realized that oil has risks. The economic ramifications will be huge.

    ShredderFeeder Reply:

    @Kathryn, “10% renewable fuel blended into our gasoline”

    Meh – that was a hand-out to the farmers and an attempt to create an artificial shortage.

    The problem with Ethanol is that the minute we comoditize food-as-fuel, you’re going to find food-prices skyrocket. Corn goes up and *EVERYTHING* goes up.

    Not to mention that corn is the single most distructive crop you can plant, it saps the soil of nutrients and after a few cycles the only thing that will grow in that land is..

    well..corn.

    Kathryn Reply:

    @ShredderFeeder, Corn isn’t the only source for ethanol. I don’t think that ethanol is anymore efficient than gasoline when you factor in the associated costs, etc. but it’s what the government is making us blend into gas at present, and it is renewable. We need to stop getting it from corn, I agree.

    Cara Reply:

    @Kathryn, My husband and I were talking last night about the irony that BP was actually one of the leaders in developing alternative energies (or at least they did a better job publicizing their efforts) and we wondered if the cost, negative publicity, etc. would harm those efforts. They’re a business, so I know there’s a self-interest there, they wanted to be positioned for whatever comes next. But, honestly, I don’t care how we get there as long as we do. I will say I don’t think they’ve handled the crisis well, and someone needs to muzzle the director of N. American operations.

    Kathryn Reply:

    @Cara, OMG I just typed a long reply to your reply and didn’t put my name in so it disappeared. !!!!!

    I agree that BP is not handling the crisis well, they should stop talking but then if they don’t say anything they’ll be lambasted for that. They can’t win right now and that’s fair enough.

    I think that the costs associated with this disaster may well impact their focus on alternative energy, but then again maybe not. They’re a hugely profitable company.

    All (or most) of the oil companies are working on alternative energy projects. One thing I think people don’t get is how long-term any new energy project, whether it’s alternative or hydrocarbon-based, is. It takes many years and billions of dollars to bring any energy project to market and start making money. The companies pay those costs themselves, but when we hear about oil company profits, we don’t hear about that.

  10. Nanna June 1, 2010 9:01 pm

    This is so good. I’m so proud of you for writing it, and for writing it so well! We do all need to do some serious thinking, now and in the long haul.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Nanna, thanks, Mama. Who would have thought you’d end up raising a tree hugger – and not Jay? lol

    Nanna Reply:

    @Miss Britt, Heh. It’s all that subconcious crap I whispered into your little baby ears for all those years. :)

  11. AmazingGreis June 1, 2010 9:29 pm

    Great post Britt! I agree 100%!!!

    I know quite a few people that are close to the BP situation. What I hate hearing is that BP isn’t doing enough, they aren’t trying hard enough. BP has crews at the site of the explosion/leak 24 hours a day. They are doing what they know how to try and get it stopped. Nothing is working. An “ACCIDENT” like this has never happened. It’s basically a guess and check game. There is no precedent to go by. How do you fix something that you don’t know how to fix? That you’ve never had to fix? If nothing else this accident will put better procedures in place for future explosions/leaks that may happen.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @AmazingGreis, I honestly don’t know if BP is doing enough. I have no real clue.

    But I know, if I’m honest with myself, that I’m not.

    Cara Reply:

    @AmazingGreis, However, they also spent alot of time and money convincing people this couldn’t happen and so they didn’t need to have a plan in place. And they had turned off the one back up safety plan that was in place. So, BP and everyone they contracted with do have a lot of responsibility in this. Even though I agree that they are scrambling now, and I feel some sympathy for the pressure they are all under.

  12. kapgar June 1, 2010 9:54 pm

    I agree with everything you said about our overdependence on oil and I’d love to see us actually do something about it. Actively. Something to cripple the oil industry. Katie and I are pricing Priuses (Prii?) for our next cars if at all possible, But it can be cost prohibitive.

    However it can’t just be us. Our government needs to take part in this. Our president and other high-ranking politicos need to sever ties from big oil funding for their campaigns. A stance like that would go far to get common citizens to join the movement.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @kapgar, of course it’s cost prohibitive – and that right there is where we all become hypocrites. (Not you specifically, lol) We cry over oiled up birds and dead fish, but we are not giving up designer coffee or jeans or mcmansions to buy more fuel efficient cars.

    And OMG YES, can you imagine what the effect it could have if politicians made a big stink about severing ties with oil???

  13. Blondefabulous June 1, 2010 10:04 pm

    We are donating $1 from every ticket sold at our next bout to clean up efforts for the gulf. If you know anyone who likes roller derby and helping out, June 19th in Sarasota FL is the place to be!!!! Anyone need more info, email me @ nicolewetherington1972@yahoo.com for ticket info!

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Blondefabulous, do you have anything on Facebook about this? I’d love to link it on the UpTake Orlando page.

    Blondefabulous Reply:

    @Miss Britt, Yes I do. I also did today’s (wednesday’s) post about it as well. Email me if you want more info.

  14. Kris June 1, 2010 10:13 pm

    I totally agree. Our out of control consumption caused this. This is the Challenger disaster of oil…and it won’t be the last, mark my words. Until we get ourselves in check this WILL NOT BE THE LAST SPILL.

    As a side note, what role did Transocean and Haliburton play in this disaster, because OH YES they did stuff wrong. It may be BP’s oil and their responsibility to clean up but what part did the other players have in BLOWING THE RIG UP?! Why don’t we hear anything about them? Obama can vilify and DECIDE that BP is responsible (before the facts and investigation are even really begun, PS: Obama I am ashamed of you) but that does not make it cut and dried does it?

    This is the Challenger of oil, the Titanic of oil. Nobody listens.

    ARGHH, it’s terrible.
    K.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Kris, “what role did Transocean and Haliburton play in this disaster” – I don’t know. Is there research on this you can point me to? Just out of curiosity, because it obviously doesn’t affect what *I* can do – but I’d still like to know.

    Wendy Reply:

    @Miss Britt, If I’m not mistaken, Transocean was responsible for the equipment at the bottom of the ocean, and Haliburton was responsible for a lot of the equipment up top. That was in the news early on, but there has been no mention of it since (at least that I have heard, but I’m not one to watch much tv…..)

    What concerns me more is that instead of pulling all our resources together to get this stopped, because no matter whose well it is, and whose at fault, it is a problem that we have created (and you did an awesome job of communicating that fact), and it has to be dealt with. Yes, BP and for that matter Shell, Exxon, Sunoco, and all the others are drilling in territory that has never been drilled in – to meet OUR demand – and there are inherent risks. Something was bound to happen at some time. And I’m sure the other oil companies are saying behind closed doors “There but for the grace of God go I.” We as a society demand the oil, and we as a society need to stop blaming everyone else and help find the solution. It really bugs me that criminal and civil law suits are already starting. That can be handled later. Get the fucking hole plugged first. Let’s all concentrate on that. Stop making BP the scapegoat in all this for now. Granted there may have been mistakes made. Hello? They are a company run by humans. We all make mistakes. Blatant wrong doing is one thing, and if that is the case, it will come out. But don’t worry about it right now. Plug the fucking hole.

    Geez I hope this sounds ok! Didn’t mean to get on my soapbox either, but I’m kind of tired of hearing political officials throwing blame around. Just help them plug the fucking hole.

    Kris Reply:

    @Wendy, PLUG THE FUCKING HOLE. Absolutely agreed!

    Kris Reply:

    @Miss Britt, I only have what I get through friends who work in oil up here, and there is A LOT of speculation that EVERYONE on that rig screwed up. Not following protocol, procedure, ignoring authority lines, blatant mismanagement, improper cementing, and it goes on and on and on. Eventually it will all come out, every little sordid detail (but no one will care by that point because the President has already ascribed blame…shame on you President Obama). BP’s not going to look like the BIG BAD people are painting them to be. After all, they seem to be the only one putting out the effort to get this sorted out. All the other companies are too busy pointing fingers and lawyering up. I wonder why that is? PS: This particular rig was a joint venture between a number of oil companies. BP just happened to be the largest of them all. Where are they? Where is their money? Why aren’t they forthcoming.
    K.

    Wendy Reply:

    @Kris, Oh yeah. You said it better than I did! I completely agree with you.

  15. ShredderFeeder June 1, 2010 10:35 pm

    The problem is, gas in the US is **CHEAP**.

    Look at it compared to European countries and it’s easy to see why we blow through petrol like it’s tap-water. (Which by the way, we also waste)

    Right now, at my local 7-11, Premium unleaded (i always count the top price) is $2.85/gal. (now that’s down almost 15c in the last month)

    Compare that to:

    London, U.K. – 5.79/gal
    Paris, France – 5.54/gal
    Amsterdam, Netherlands – 6.48/gal

    Maybe if gas prices were higher we wouldn’t consume as much, if maybe driving was a little more painful we would find a way to wean ourselves off fossil fuels.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @ShredderFeeder, you’re absolutely right. And again – we buy it because we CAN, whether we should or not.

    Like big houses.

    But our gluttony is catching up with us in more ways than one.

    ShredderFeeder Reply:

    @Miss Britt, Its why I actually don’t complain that gas prices go up and I *ALWAYS* vote for whatever new gas-tax is being proposed. I figure #1 it helps raise money for some project or another, and #2 it discourages people from being piggy/wasteful.

    Cara Reply:

    @ShredderFeeder, Amen. My husband and I were trying to figure out last night if there was a way to increase gas taxes enough that it would actually change behaviors without creating the huge public outcry that makes it politically unfeasible. We didn’t come up with anything, though.

  16. The Tutugirl June 1, 2010 10:50 pm

    YES. Oh god, yes.

    Thanks for the reminder of why I take the extra ten minutes to walk to the train instead of driving four blocks. Now I just need to work on the rest…

    ShredderFeeder Reply:

    @The Tutugirl, I wish I had one close enough. Nearest metro stop for me is literally 25 miles away.

    I drive my Prius to the metro and metro into DC from there.

    Just doing my part. ;-)

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @The Tutugirl, I want so badly to live in a place where I can take a bus or train.

  17. avitable June 1, 2010 11:48 pm

    Well, this is definitely one area where you and I disagree! :) Could’ve been a good “Clearly You’re Retarded” topic!

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @avitable, I’m sorry, which area do you disagree with?

    That oil spills are bad?
    That we are the largest consumer of oil in the world?
    That every drop of the oil we produce in this country is to satisfy our own consumption?

    Which of those statements are you actually going to try to argue with in your attempts to change your beliefs to match your habits, instead of the other way around?

    Nanna Reply:

    @Miss Britt, sitting back, popping popcorn and waiting for the debate. :)

    avitable Reply:

    @Miss Britt, I disagree that we have any responsibility for it. It’s a byproduct of enjoying the luxuries that we rightfully deserve. In addition, companies like BP have lobbied aggressively against electric vehicles and more efficient hybrids (better than the ones out there now), so those products don’t exist on the market except in very limited quantities.

    If there was a V6 or V8 car that didn’t use gas that cost the same as my current car and had the same durability, pickup and speed capabilities, I’d buy that instead. But there’s not, and that’s not my fault. I refuse to be punished because lobbyists have retarded our entry into better efficiency.

    ShredderFeeder Reply:

    @avitable, But the act of “I’ll buy what I want because I refuse to be punished..” creates the market that they’re feeding.

    As long as people will buy the big gas-guzzling behemoths…they’ll keep making them. Auto-makers only exist to fulfil the need. The minute we don’t demand them, they’ll stop making them.

    Nyt Reply:

    @avitable, A “by-product of the luxuries that we rightfully deserve”??? Holy Entitle-itis Batman!!

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Nyt, exactly.

  18. Lisa June 2, 2010 12:16 am

    I agree, there needs to be alternatives. I have a few opinions on why there aren’t, but that’s not the point of this piece. In our house we try to do what we can. Public transportation isn’t an option where we live so we traded in one of our guzzling Jeeps for a fuel-friendlier Toyota. We recycle and re-use. Even so, we could do more. We can always do more.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Lisa, Jared and I are seriously discussing what to do with our Trailblazer, which he used to need for work.

    It pisses me off that there aren’t more options because I know the technology exists. We need to make our demands louder, I think. And we do that with our dollars.

  19. Socrates June 2, 2010 7:53 am

    An evil by-product of our consumer nature? There’s a good few of them. Price of fuel here in the UK has been increasing at a ridiculous rate, and the falling value of our currency hasn’t helped. But it has really focused people’s attention on fuel efficient travel. It is totally driven by cost however, and not the environment, as I fear it almost always certainly be.

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Socrates, there are a good few of them, indeed. I’d like to hope that we can collectively have some kind of philosophical awakening.

  20. Karen Sugarpants June 2, 2010 9:20 am

    Your google ad above this post right now says the BP Spill should be blamed on Obama. I’m pretty sure he wasn’t there…

    Seriously though – I agree.

    Robin Reply:

    @Karen Sugarpants, depending on who you talk to, EVERYTHING should be blamed on Obama. :)

  21. Finn June 2, 2010 9:36 am

    I agree with what you’re saying, and I think we all need to look at our own behavior and our own part in this. But.

    First, apparently BP could have installed a part that may have prevented this at a cost of only $500,000. Considering how much this debacle is costing them and how much profit they make annually, that half mil is pocket change. Just sayin’.

    Secondly, before you were born we had a gas crisis that included shortages and long lines at the pump. More than 30 years ago we got a warning. By now all vehicles should be hybrid at the very least if not electric. We should have more access to alternative sources such as wind and solar. But we don’t. In fact we are more dependent on oil than we were in the 70s.

    The truth is, the oil industry employs a lot of people. And it donates tons of money to politicians. This, in turn, blocks a lot of efforts to change the situation. In the end, money wins.

    It will take a lot of pressure on our part to change things. We The People must change our behavior on a massive scale so that companies do not profit from wasteful products like huge SUVs.

    We have our work cut out for us.

    Kris Reply:

    @Finn, I want to know what you know about the part that could have been installed for $500,000. Because as far as I am concerned (and this I know for a fact) the blow out preventer that FAILED is the GOLD STANDARD in the oil industry. What else were they supposed to use, really, do tell?

    Finn Reply:

    @Kris, I may be wrong on the numbers as I saw something on CNN while on the treadmill and possibly misinterpreted it (there was no closed captioning), but I believe this what they were talking about: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/27/us/27rig.html

    Kris Reply:

    @Finn, Knowing a bit about industry standards in the oil industry I know that there are two differences between the types of casings used in “producing” versus “exploratory” wells/drilling. The casing type BP used is the industry standard for wells that will actually produce oil (almost every single well in production right now will have the type BP used). The other casing (the one according to the article stated as the “less risky” one) is used in exploratory wells (a well that is drilled to see if there is actually oil where a company thinks it is, and if oil is found is capped off, abandoned and a producing well is drilled in close proximity). It needs to be more robust because an exploratory well is not usually used as a producing well HOWEVER, in the last 10-20 years that has been changing. Hence, the controversy around the type of casing used.

    My point really isn’t that though. My point is that we shouldn’t believe everything we see on the news. And why is a Congressional Investigator leaking informations to the New York Times from an active investigation? Everything about this investigation and oil leak, from every angle is crap. Let’s just blame BP because Obama says so. (I was an Obama supporter and now I think he’s an idiot).

    Finn Reply:

    @Kris, I’m more likely to believe what I hear from the news than what I hear from a large corporation. Part of my job is to write press releases. I am quite familiar with spin. I do realize the press don’t always get it right, but it is not unheard of for a corporation to cut corners to either save a few bucks or make a few extra ones.

  22. Headless Mom June 2, 2010 12:25 pm

    Best thing I’ve read on the subject, period. Slinging mud (no pun intended) isn’t going to get it cleaned up: it only pisses everyone off more. What you’re talking about will actually DO something about the problem. Well said, Britt.

  23. hello haha narf June 2, 2010 5:15 pm

    i’m guilty of driving my large seven passenger vehicle and loving it. then i see images of dying dolphins and turtles and i sob.

    which kind of leads me to a different subject. why aren’t there more images of the lives this oil is taking? how is bp seemingly keeping the reports limited to aerial views and not getting the country truly outraged at the vast loss of lives?

    Kris Reply:

    @hello haha narf, I don’t think BP has anything to do with it, unless you subscribe to conspiracy theory. Personally, I’ve seen quite a number of articles and pictures of oil laden animals. I have also heard a lot of speculation that dolphins that they are finding dead are dying from other “unknown issues unrelated to the oil”. I am interested in what those are (drowning from fishing nets that weren’t brought in before the spill?) Who knows.

    hello haha narf Reply:

    @Kris,
    i don’t subscribe to any conspiracy theories about this. just saying i haven’t seen nearly the images i did back when the valdez dumped all that oil into the ocean…and i wasn’t really even on the computer that much back then.
    and for the record, other unknown issues, my ass.

  24. Robin June 2, 2010 8:06 pm

    I agree with your entire post, Britt. My parents refreshed my memory about the Oil Crisis that came BR, BR being Before Robin (was born….). It’s sad that we can’t (or won’t) figure out different ways to lessen our dependence on oil.

    I think we take our oil availability for granted. We may bitch and moan about how much it costs, yet we still buy 28 gallon SUVs or V8 cars…although my CR-V is only 16 gallons, if I had it to do all over again I would have invested in a Prius. Looking back, you gotta wonder what’s more “expensive…..”

    muskrat Reply:

    @Robin, unless you buy a used hybrid and keep it a long ass time (like 10 years), you save money by buying a “regular” car. i’ve done the math (even with the tax breaks that used to be there).

  25. muskrat June 2, 2010 9:27 pm

    Hey, I live in the fucking ‘hood so that I’m close to work and art and sports (and crime and shitty schools)! No commuter lifestyle for me! And our meat and veggies come from a local farm! And I drive a 4-cylinder!

    I like BP. They’re part of the S&P 500, and I have a shitload of money in an index fund that mirrors the S&P 500, so when BP does well, our family does well.

    So basically, this post just flew by me and landed on someone else.

  26. mare June 2, 2010 9:34 pm

    typo…

    and look for products that *aren’t* grown or made closer to home.

    But pretty damn brilliant woman.

  27. Jose Bay June 3, 2010 7:49 am

    Miss Britt; let me take a somewhat metaphysical, rebellious or nihilist POV on your nicely written & thought provoking article.

    I don’t think people will be won over by reasoning faceting extremes & anonymous scatter brain blame saying ‘we Americans did this’ or ‘we Australians did this’ or ‘we Asians did this’.

    I am going to be sceptical about the accounting/data gathering resources of ‘Americans being the biggest consumers in the world’. Ostensibly it feels, reads & looks right. But, the majority of the world are 2nd to 3rd world countries that have unreliable statistical & raw data crunching capabilities on consumer units, price index, import, export & what have you (not to mention buergeoning exploding populations numbers throwing records in disarray). So in my reality, we may never know if Brazil, India or Russia are the most damaging polluting countries.

    I think most aspiring & liberal minded Westerners react apathetically & belittle environmental movements. The reality is, individuals live in a cocoon of micro small family social units. No one’s gonna ever gather an army of green protesters who can tangibly see all the ‘arguable & disputable carnage’ humans may, or may NOT do – let alone on a ‘grand omnipresent, overseeing revealing scale’. & do you really think rival conglomerates/big business companies in petrol, car manufacturing etc. would see their customers, or rivals effect on the environment, or whatever ‘point of comparison area’? I seriously doubt it Miss Britt. I mean it’s like giving away FBI/CIA defence secrets to your rivals.

    I really believe one person can NOT make a difference; & this floats over to them realising their green house consumption footprints is like a speck of sand…on the endless beaches of the planet Earth. Sure, I try & do recycle as much as possible. I don’t fall for buying 3D TVs or buying a new PC every 2 years. I prefer to live life to moderate environmentally friendly & sustainability principles. But I am NOT gonna do so under the gun of The Day After Tomorrow bandwagon, anti-globalisation fervour, extemist reasoning & warped paranoia. Many have said some parts of the green movement are nothing more than money making Ponzi schemes, e.g. Amway-like, bogus pyramid selling of $100 green friendly shampoo to your neighbours & hackneyed acquaintances.

    Miss Britt: thanks for your article, you hit a dormant point that I procrastinated to one day write a blog or forum rant about. Rock on MB.

    Jose Bay Reply:

    @Jose Bay, what I meant to say at the start of the 5th paragraph is I could turn on the lights of a house I live in, full blast the oven & spa for 3 days straight – but it won’t make one iota of a difference to the weather, or future oil tankers sinking or not. The only effect will be on me & less than 10 people who will have to pay triple the electricity bills for that quarter. Case closed your honour;)?

    Miss Britt Reply:

    @Jose Bay, “But, the majority of the world are 2nd to 3rd world countries that have unreliable statistical & raw data crunching capabilities on consumer units, price index, import, export & what have you (not to mention buergeoning exploding populations numbers throwing records in disarray). So in my reality, we may never know if Brazil, India or Russia are the most damaging polluting countries.”

    I’m not arguing about what countries are the biggest polluters. Because oil is a commodity that is not produced and/or sold by just anyone, it’s consumption is actually something that can be measured fairly easily.

    As to the rest of your comment – you kind of lost me on most of it, which isn’t to say that you aren’t correct or don’t have valid points, but rather that I’m not at all clear on what, exactly, you were trying to say with that bit about FBI/CIA secrets and micro units.

    ANYway, I wholeheartedly disagree with the idea that one person can’t make a difference. I think that’s something we tell ourselves to justify our fear of change and failure. “It won’t matter anyway, why bother?” At the core, I believe that way of thinking is cowardly.

  28. Kaycee June 3, 2010 7:49 am

    Amen.

  29. Ashley, the Accidental Olympian June 3, 2010 10:50 am

    I love this idea that WE all made this mess.

    Thank you for sharing.

  30. Elizabeth Kaylene June 3, 2010 12:20 pm

    I love the Gulf, too. I just love the ocean in general, and this mess breaks my heart. I didn’t even know that we were drilling for oil underwater until this whole thing happened. How’s that for uninformed?

    It terrifies me that this is happening. I think of all of the Dawn commercials I’ve seen, where people clean up animals who have been covered with oil because of spills, and all I can think of is, “No amount of Dawn is going to make this better.”

    I know that everyone — especially green people and environmentalists — is getting up in arms with this and getting angry with BP (which they have a right to), but you’re right; we should also put the responsibility on ourselves. We all need to seriously rethink how much oil we use. We could be independent of relying on other countries if we only cut down on the amount of oil we use.

    I too want to live in a town where everything is in walking distance. (The first place that comes to mind is Deerfield Beach, Florida, my first love.) More cities and towns should be set up that way, where walking, biking, and public transportation are more predominant than driving.

    Lately, I’ve been really wanting to buy a bike, because I loved riding a bicycle as a kid and because I could really use the exercise. I think I’ll start saving up for that bike now.

  31. Selma June 3, 2010 8:13 pm

    I think you’re right but Adam has also raised a very fair point and that is that the oil companies actively lobby against alternative fuels. An engine run completely on hydrogen was invented over 30 years ago. The development of that technology was quashed by the oil industry. That is just one example. A friend of mine built a solar car which he drove right round Australia. And that was over ten years ago. He couldn’t get funding for it.

    For me the major problem is government policy. All over the world we, the people, need to put more pressure on government to incorporate alternative fuel technologies into the system. The power of the oil lobby needs to be removed. That will be the only way things like this will stop happening.

    I think your post highlights that we need to all be more accountable than we presently are. We need to take the green movement out of the hands of the activists and insist on it being implemented into our local communities. We can do that by the way we shop, the way we drive, the way we live, the way we vote. It is possible.

    Excellent post, Britt.

  32. Tina@Send Chocolate Now June 4, 2010 10:31 pm

    Great post, Britt. I wrote a post about the disaster..and what I plan to do about it:

    http://www.sendchocolatenow.com/2010/06/how-to-show-you-mean-business-vote-with.html

  33. Cara June 6, 2010 12:57 pm

    Before I got caught up in the thought-provoking and interesting comments, I was thinking that what you said about personal responsibility is right on. There’s a limit to what I can do about someone else’s behavior, but I can control my own. Two years ago or so I was choosing one environmentally-friendly change to make per month, usually something small. (We already chose gas efficient cars and a short commute.) One month we installed a thermostat with a timer for our AC, another I switched to petroleum free detergents, and yet another I started using my reusable bags for every store (because I’m slow sometimes and was only using them for the groceries). Most of those changes or new habits have lasted and really don’t take any extra effort on my part. I’m not sure why or when I stopped picking a new thing each month, but after reading your post I’m going to start again.

  34. Rev. Daniel W. Blair June 26, 2010 2:53 pm

    As we enter one of the most aggressive hurricane seasons on record, I cannot even imagine what a hurricane would do with oil in the Gulf of Mexico. Dealing with oil on the beach is one thing, but what if we had to deal with it in our streets, in our businesses, in our homes? What if we had to rescue humans covered in oil? What if this is no longer isolated to just the Gulf Coast but found its way up the great rivers to our inner cities? Now imagine if you will, the dispersants mixed with oil which could possibly cause untold diseases and catastrophic health hazards of a biblical proportion. It staggers the imagination, or is it prophetic? What if we are dealing with the wrath of God? Author of the book Final Warning

More Blog Posts

Previous Post: